
After ranking the RB's in terms of expected fantasy output last week I thought I'd start on the QB's this week. This time though I'll make it a three-part affair so as to provide rationale or commentary for each choice. Again, these are subject to change significantly within a few weeks. Without further ado:
1. Peyton Manning: The most consistent player in fantasy leagues. He's already been the best statistical quarterback in the league, and given my analysis of the colts' defense this year, Manning may find himself trailing more than usual and his production could actually increase (if that's possible.) The maturation of Addai and the addition of Anthony Gonzalez should help - clear cut #1 here is Manning.
2. Carson Palmer: This is kind of a tough spot, because there are a few QB's you could slot in here, but given that I think their production will be roughly the same, I'm going with Palmer because I feel he's the safest pick. He's reached a level of consistency where he's automatic to have a better than 2:1 TD-INT ratio and exceed 3500 yards with 25 TD's. I consider that a worst case scenario (assuming he's healthy) whereas the best case is something like 36 TD 10 INT 4300 yds. He is in his prime and his weapons are still in their primes, expect him to have a good year.
3. Drew Brees: I'm a little less confident with this choice because it's not a lock that Brees has a year like he did last year, given that guys like Colston could regress. Still though the playcalling down in New Orleans is great, he still has a great pair of RB's to work with and the wide recievers should still be good if not great with the addition of meachem.
4. Marc Bulger: I didn't really appreciate how good Bulger was until I looked at his stats. He has been putting up consistently very good numbers, and I don't see it stopping this year. At 30 he is in his prime, with a top 3 RB to work with and a very able set of wideouts led by Holt and bolstered by the addition of Bennett.
5. Tom Brady: Debated putting him ahead of Bulger, but I think Bulger is safer at 4. Brady has the potential this year to be all the way at #2 if Moss and Stallworth stay healthy the whole year and perform up to their potential. Brady would have two of the best deep threats in the game and I'd imagine would rack up a ton of TD's with elite end-zone threats in Moss, Watson, Stallworth. However, there's a risk factor with those guys, Moss could be old and Stallworth could be injured. Even if they are Brady's a safe bet to put up good numbers, and I don't think you could let him slip past this spot.
6. Donovan Mcnabb: No clear-cut choice in my mind here. However, Mcnabb put up the 9th best production last year....in only 10 games! He was on pace for over 4200 yds passing before a knee injury derailed him. This year I expect his mobility to be hindered, but he should be due for a healthy season and I expect him to be in the 3800-4000 yd range. Losing stallworth hurt a little bit, but the eagles' coordinating is great, and you still have brown and westbrook at the very least.
7. Phillip Rivers: Phil was in the top 10 in production last season, all while being "managed" by schottenheimer and Cam Cameron. Although he's a 2nd year starter he's a 4th year QB and I expect him to have even more of a breakout year. Although Norv Turner like to run in the red zone, he should turn Rivers loose more than Schottenheimer did. We already know about LT and Antonio Gates, but Eric Parker is very underrated and Craig Davis has the potential to be a real asset to Rivers. I'd feel very confident taking him in this spot.
8. Ben Roethlisberger: If you feel this defies logic, good for you. Call it a hunch, but I think Ben and the Steelers will be back with a vengance this season. Hines Ward should be as good as ever, and I see Santonio Holmes, Heath Miller and Willie Parker all on a serious upswing. From what I've heard the new OC is partial to opening things up for Ben, which should mean more production. If a very good 3rd option at WR develops this year, look out for the Steelers. I'm aware they'll still run a lot, but I see ben getting a lot of production out of the deep ball, as well as the fact that Parker can really RAC on short dump offs and screens. I see the steelers scoring a lot of touchdowns this year. It's pretty much a make or break year for Roethlisberger, and although he's no lock - I'd bet on him.
9. Jon Kitna: Again, probably seems like a wild pick. What you need to realize is that INT's just don't penalize you much, and we know that Kitna is going to be throwing the ball like it's going out of style. The Lions will trail early and late and Kitna will be airing it out big time. He was already in the top 10 in terms of fantasy production last year, and now you add Calvin Johnson to the mix? Kitna may not have to do much besides let it rip and let Roy Williams and Calvin Johnson track it down. This pick has high bust potential because Kitna could be replaced if the Lions struggle, but I still think he has value at #9.
10. Vince Young: He didn't even start the first couple games and still ended up at #11 in production. While at first I thought that Young's loss of weapons such as Bennett and Henry would hinder him, I realized that it could actually cause his fantasy production to increase. I'm sure the Titans will still try to run a fair amount, but probably to little avail. The titans are likely to be in a lot of 3rd down situations, and a lot of "come from behind" situations late. This should mean a lot of passing plays for Young, and hopefully if you're a fantasy owner a lot of scrambling. Let's be honest, even if VY develops as a passer this year, he's not going to be throwing a boatload of TD's. What I'd hope for and expect is that VY will have to take care of things himself, which should entail a lot of scrambling and therefore points. Injury risk is a major concern so again I wouldn't feel safe taking him here, if he fell to 15 or so I'd snap him up in a hurry. Still I don't think there's anyone at this spot with more potential.